Ladies and Gentlemen,
You have heard of Singapore run by the Lee ruling family, trying to improve it's image by trying to attract the world's best university, Yale, to enter a joint venture with it's university.
A country whose courts willingly allow themselves to be used as tools to punish political detractors through libel actions, which controls the entire media as it is done in North Korea and where even a one man peaceful protest results in arrest and imprisonment should not be trying this with the most prestigious university in the USA, a democracy.
It appears Yale wants nothing to with a a country like Singapore. Instead of trying this with USA, I am sure Kim Jong An's Pyongyang University would be very willing. Singapore should go where they are appreciated.
Elizabeth Peiris puts it very well in her article.
http://www.freemalaysiatoday.com/category/opinion/2012/04/12/singapore-getting-an-%E2%80%98education%E2%80%99/
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Singapore getting an ‘education’
April 12, 2012
The vision is to make this island-republic become Asia’s premier education and knowledge hub, a long cherished dream.
By Elizabeth Peiris
Singapore authorities are presumably getting an ‘education’! For weeks on end now the city-state has been embroiled in a tussle of sorts to snagging America’s leading university of Yale.
Authorities are envisioning a collaborative pact the Ivy League university and Singapore’s National University of Singapore (NUS) will ease the way to helping the republic realise its long standing quest of becoming Asia’s premier education and knowledge hub.
A pact with Yale though, already exists with NUS for medical exploration and joint study. But because of the somewhat ‘harmless’ nature of that agreement wherein there rarely is an issue of making public controversial findings, that arrangement passed without incident or hitch.
But the present arrangement NUS hopes to clinch is far from the incendiary world of consensual and collegial consent of joint studies and explorative findings.
Its essence is much about differing political and cultural values. In so far as the contextual reading of the subject matter is concerned, it actually pits one form of governance against another.
There really is no mistaking about what Yale’s credentials are apart from having produced some notable US leaders.
It has the largest endowment fund which is equal to the Gross Domestic Fund of some Third World nations. It also has one of the strictest admission criteria anywhere in the world.
“In fact it is one of the top two universities in the United States” says a US resident living in Singapore.
With such sterling credentials, it therefore is little wonder the NUS would want to team up with Yale as that will allow the latter to gain international heft to attract, retain and undertake seminal projects on its home turf and across Asia.
The cachet of Yale is so very vital for the NUS, because the city-state has always harped extensively on its credentials that it is a meritocracy.
Singapore not a talent meritocracy
But as Singapore is finding out, it is not always hunky-dory when it comes to snagging some of the world’s ‘best’. Because just as the world’s supposed best may themselves be musing, the stakes for them too could pretty high when they are seen negotiating with a nation not well known for its political liberalism or tolerance of opposing viewpoints.
In interviews with newspapers the city-state’s Deputy Prime Minister Tharman Shanmugaratnam views the tie-up as a ‘cancelling’ the shortfalls brought on by Singapore’s exam-smart meritocracy vis-à-vis America’s talent-led meritocracy.
Shanmugaratnam minced no words over to which system he was seeking first and foremost.
Without acknowledging outrightly he let it be known that Singapore’s system of education has not been at its sterling best as it had has commonly touted to be as. In short it was not delivering!
The mere fact the nation has to continually look beyond its shores for talent despite a very stressful and rigorous system second only to Japan – the latest being the former chief of Malaysian state-owned oil company, Petronas, Hassan Marican – is but an indication its education system is quite not what it was cracked up to be in terms of unleashing creativity, drive and entrepreneurship and leadership qualities; character traits the nation needs so very vitally out of its young populace to continually to stay ahead of other regional economies.
The on-going saga is proving to be something of a déjà vu for Singapore. Only some seven years ago the same argument now used by Yale University was also used by another prestigious university, Warwick in the United Kingdom.
Warwick’s concern was the stifling political environment in Singapore would make the city-state an inhospitable place to undertake unfettered research coupled with the latent fear of interference from the city-state’s political elite.
In a statement to foreign media outlets Warwick said, ”In the absence of a positive commitment from the academic community, [the university] resolves not to proceed with the plan for a second comprehensive campus of the University of Warwick, in Singapore”.
There is little by way of assertion to understand just how Yale itself may be feeling especially in light of the sentiments expressed by Warwick to foreign media outlets.
The university’s senate then in 2005 voted overwhelmingly to reject any move to Singapore as it argued it would threaten the Warwick ‘way of life’ when a Singaporean relocation is in the offing.
The question of academic freedom has understandably made many a foreign university leery of forming collaborative pacts with the city-state.
Since the early 1990s and the transformation of the private education industry through its private education council, that some in the city-state have been taking issue with it in the arbitrary way it awards licences for the recruitment of foreign students; Singapore has always aimed at becoming the premier nation of choice for learning, experimentation and eventually of cutting-edge discoveries the way the Swiss have always been.
A few foreign universities do maintain campuses in the city-state but none enjoy the Ivy-League ‘halo’ as Yale or Warwick does.
Maybe it is the turn of the city planners themselves to get some lessons – some hard lessons in life on what it needs to do to get the best in the world to come ashore.
Elizabeth Peiris is a Singapore-based freelance writer.
Friday, April 13, 2012
Thursday, April 12, 2012
Singapore Lee's courts and "part time cleaners"
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Singaporeans have been following an unusual strange case in their courts, since it is not very often for an ordinary citizen, to challenge the all powerful government of the Lee ruling family let alone a "part time cleaner".
Nearly 3 months ago, an opposition Member of Parliament (I use the word opposition in a rather loose Singaporean sense, meaning that he is in fact too afraid to challenge the government on anything real) for the constituency of Hougang was expelled after his infidelity was reveled, which required the government to hold by- elections.
To force the government, as they appeared to be delaying, a citizen of that ward, Vellama Marie Muthu,aged 42, who happens to be a "part time cleaner" in the government housing agency, took an action in court asking for an order that they hold by-elections in Hougang without further delay.
Other than the the uniqueness of any legal action against Singapore's all powerful Lee family which no one has won, let alone by a humble citizen which has no chance at all, what is interesting is the way it's state controlled newspapers describe the plaintiff.
PART TIME CLEANER
In every single report in these state controlled newspapers one phrase keeps recurring, the words "part time cleaner" to describe the Plaintiff.
http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC120413-0000041/Hougang-by-election-case--AGCs-appeal-in-week-beginning-May-14
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788296.html
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1194739/1/.html
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788018.html
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788018.html
This repetition of her social standing in society speaks reams of what Singapore has become today, an elitist class conscious society where "part time cleaners" should not be going around doing things like this. What these reports are doing is stating exactly what their government thinks of citizens of humbler circumstances such as this woman Vellama Marie Muthu.
These Lee ruling family newspapers are trying to say that the very fact that a part time cleaner should be suing the government at all is a surprise by itself. It would be slightly different had Vellama been a multi millionaire banker, when Lee's judges would perhaps have looked at the whole thing a little differently, but not here coming from a "part time cleaner"!
It is unheard of for anyone to sue the government let alone "part time cleaners". She probably earns $1,000 or less, which is an almost non existent minute decimal of what Lee Kuan Yew or his son earns of $4.7 million a year, 5 times the salary of the President of the United States.
In fact, you would know this if you knew Singapore. What the Lee ruling family is trying to say through their newspapers is that this part time cleaner woman shouldn't be wasting her time going around suing the government. She should know better. Such things are for rich people, not "part time cleaners".
She should consider herself lucky that she even has a job. What she should be doing is to realize her very poorly situation. She is not a notch above the lowest of the low. She should be lucky to be alive. Women like her should not have megalomaniacal ideas.
By this repeated references to "part time cleaner" suing the government, they are trying to tell her that they are going to teach her a lesson she will never forget. The judge on the orders of the Lee family will promptly throw the case out, she would be ordered to pay costs of $50,000 if not more. And not having the money she would be bankrupted and last but not least she would be thrown out of even that measly job.
Lee's Singapore government is going to kill her like they kill the proverbial Chinese chicken so as to frighten all the Singaporean monkeys, I mean citizens.
There was never in Singapore's history anyone who had the courage to sue Lee Kuan Yew's government and there never will be; that is, someone who has done it and lived to tell the tale.
Who does she think she is, this "part time cleaner" in Lee family's Singapore, Margaret Thather?
This is how Singapore's Lee ruling family and their government thinks of their ordinary citizens. Millionaires, are treated a little better.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Singaporeans have been following an unusual strange case in their courts, since it is not very often for an ordinary citizen, to challenge the all powerful government of the Lee ruling family let alone a "part time cleaner".
Nearly 3 months ago, an opposition Member of Parliament (I use the word opposition in a rather loose Singaporean sense, meaning that he is in fact too afraid to challenge the government on anything real) for the constituency of Hougang was expelled after his infidelity was reveled, which required the government to hold by- elections.
To force the government, as they appeared to be delaying, a citizen of that ward, Vellama Marie Muthu,aged 42, who happens to be a "part time cleaner" in the government housing agency, took an action in court asking for an order that they hold by-elections in Hougang without further delay.
Other than the the uniqueness of any legal action against Singapore's all powerful Lee family which no one has won, let alone by a humble citizen which has no chance at all, what is interesting is the way it's state controlled newspapers describe the plaintiff.
PART TIME CLEANER
In every single report in these state controlled newspapers one phrase keeps recurring, the words "part time cleaner" to describe the Plaintiff.
http://www.todayonline.com/Singapore/EDC120413-0000041/Hougang-by-election-case--AGCs-appeal-in-week-beginning-May-14
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788296.html
http://www.channelnewsasia.com/stories/singaporelocalnews/view/1194739/1/.html
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788018.html
http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_788018.html
This repetition of her social standing in society speaks reams of what Singapore has become today, an elitist class conscious society where "part time cleaners" should not be going around doing things like this. What these reports are doing is stating exactly what their government thinks of citizens of humbler circumstances such as this woman Vellama Marie Muthu.
These Lee ruling family newspapers are trying to say that the very fact that a part time cleaner should be suing the government at all is a surprise by itself. It would be slightly different had Vellama been a multi millionaire banker, when Lee's judges would perhaps have looked at the whole thing a little differently, but not here coming from a "part time cleaner"!
It is unheard of for anyone to sue the government let alone "part time cleaners". She probably earns $1,000 or less, which is an almost non existent minute decimal of what Lee Kuan Yew or his son earns of $4.7 million a year, 5 times the salary of the President of the United States.
In fact, you would know this if you knew Singapore. What the Lee ruling family is trying to say through their newspapers is that this part time cleaner woman shouldn't be wasting her time going around suing the government. She should know better. Such things are for rich people, not "part time cleaners".
She should consider herself lucky that she even has a job. What she should be doing is to realize her very poorly situation. She is not a notch above the lowest of the low. She should be lucky to be alive. Women like her should not have megalomaniacal ideas.
By this repeated references to "part time cleaner" suing the government, they are trying to tell her that they are going to teach her a lesson she will never forget. The judge on the orders of the Lee family will promptly throw the case out, she would be ordered to pay costs of $50,000 if not more. And not having the money she would be bankrupted and last but not least she would be thrown out of even that measly job.
Lee's Singapore government is going to kill her like they kill the proverbial Chinese chicken so as to frighten all the Singaporean monkeys, I mean citizens.
There was never in Singapore's history anyone who had the courage to sue Lee Kuan Yew's government and there never will be; that is, someone who has done it and lived to tell the tale.
Who does she think she is, this "part time cleaner" in Lee family's Singapore, Margaret Thather?
This is how Singapore's Lee ruling family and their government thinks of their ordinary citizens. Millionaires, are treated a little better.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Wednesday, April 11, 2012
Singapore. Letter from David D'Aranjo stating no thanks for Lee Kuan Yew award.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Following is a letter from David D'Aranjo on what he thinks of Lee Kuan Yew's award to New York City. I think he is saying that if they want to give that award, they should do it to Pyongyang, North Korea, Harare Zimbabwe or Havana Cuba. They deserve it more than New York city
Best Regards
Gopalan Nair
Fremont, CA, USA
Fwd: NYC is not LKY's "World City".
TO: More recipientsCC: recipientsYou MoreBCC: recipientsYou
Hide Details FROM:Dave D'aranjo Message flagged Thursday, March 22, 2012 2:09 AMA copy of my letter to Singapore's prime minister, Lee Hsien Loong.
Begin forwarded message:
From: Dave D'aranjo
Subject: NYC is not LKY's "World City".
Date: March 22, 2012 5:04:06 AM EDT
To: lee_hsien_loong@pmo.gov.sg, kishore.mahbubani@mahbubani.net
Cc: PMO HQ, gavin_chelvan@pmo.gov.sg, gavin_shelvan@pmo.gov.sg
Mr. Lee Hsien Loong.
My name is Dave D'aranjo. I have written before.
I am an ex-Singaporean. Your government threatened me with conscription, jail, and/or exile because I did not agree to so-called "universal" conscription. Your military determined that I must be mentally incompetent to hold these views. I renounced my citizenship and was compelled to move to the US, away from home, family, friends, etc.
I was too naive to understand what was happening to me and my family at the time, but suffice to say it seemed earth-shattering.
I will never forget your government's actions against me, and the damage your policies caused to my happiness and sense of home.
I hold you and your father personally responsible - and I am not alone.
When Singapore rejected me, I came to New York City.
New York City offered me a home and acceptance for who I am and what I believe, as long as it meant peace.
Thus I primarily consider myself a New Yorker - by choice and by circumstance.
As a New Yorker, and I would like to tell you that you may pat Mayor Bloomberg on the back and think you both are friends, but the truth is that NYC needs an award from Singapore like a fish needs a bicycle.
Especially an award named after Lee Kuan Yew.
You and your government have no concept of individual liberty, which is - if anything - what NYC represents. The very spirit the of the city is individualistic. Yet your government demands conformity, and the penalties are harsh indeed.
To quote Professor Kishore Mahbubani in the article "New York City gets Lee Kuan Yew prize":
"So [for Singapore] to become the iconic city of the Asian century, we must learn to be more open, accept diversity and take full advantage of it - the way New York City did." - (TodayOnline.com, March 22, 2012)
Why don't you take Professor Mahbubani's advice already? You are failing to perceive and act upon the progressively liberal opinions of Singapore's youth, who are increasingly exasperated and embarrassed about the PAP's authoritarian policies, reliance on "foreign talent", and international reputation. I once had a great love and hope for Singapore, which has (clearly) been decimated.
You may say, "David, that's your view, and you are entitled to it". As an American citizen, I am certainly entitled to a dissenting view. It is a Constitutional right, and there are plenty of advocacy groups that strive for the peaceful reform of government over here. The US is far from perfect, but I am not particularly afraid to speak out. In the news, I witness both great tragedy and great success every day - initiated and effected by the people.
Do Singaporeans really have the right to speak out if they so wish? If I remained a Singaporean, the public expression of these views would put me at risk of censure, detention without limit, jail, lawsuits for defamation that I couldn't hope to afford.... tactics you and your father have capitalized upon in the past with "great success".
It is dirty politics and very much against the grassroots activism that New York City allows for. It is not in the spirit of transformation and 'accepting diversity'. If any American official followed your example, impeachment might not be far behind.
For this reason, let me say that: as long as Singapore is a conservative, restrictive, uptight society that permits corporal punishment, capital punishment, conscription, censorship, and horrendous colonial laws under the false term "Asian Values" -- mark my words -- Singapore will never, ever, EVER in a million years reach the intellectual, historic, humanitarian, scientific and artistic depth that New York City has achieved. Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak somewhat agrees (linked article).
I am angered by your pompous gall at bestowing this made-up "Lee Kuan Yew World City" award to my adoptive home. By naming the award after Lee Kuan Yew, you have undermined the earnest intent of recognizing urban development. The award now reeks of nepotistic authoritarianism.
There's an old expression in New York City -- commonly said; it rhymes with "duck you, you ducking duck".
Let me be the first New Yorker to convey this expression to all involved.
David D'aranjo
On Nov 13, 2008, at 8:31 PM, Dave D'aranjo wrote:
You've no doubt received my previous two emails.
Answer the questions specifically.
David
On Nov 5, 2008, at 8:17 PM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 31 Oct 2008.
2. We had addressed your issues raised in our earlier replies dated 13 Oct 2008, 23 Oct 2008 and 29 Oct 2008, and will not be making further clarifications on this matter.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/31/2008 05:21 PM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO Hsien Loong LEE/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Hi Elizabeth,
I beg to differ - you have not addressed the issues raised, and I am increasingly alarmed that an organization that demands so much is unable to legibly and specifically defend it's own existence.
This is as succinct as I can possibly make my three questions.
Please answer them directly:
1. What options do you offer those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Please outline what penalties or alternatives are involved.
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
I'm asking for three answers, and a couple moments of your time towards a personalized reply.
You ask - no, demand - three years of a young man's life, evidently "no questions asked".
I demand answers as to why I was made to feel like a traitor in a homeland that I otherwise love dearly, simply because I do not believe in participating in the military or police apparatus.
If this were a question of forced religious conscription - vital to "moral" security and defense of a nation - I suspect we'd agree on that scenario's unfair and backwards nature.
I just ask that you be specific; I will not be making further concessions on this matter.
David D'aranjo
On Oct 29, 2008, at 6:25 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 23 Oct 2008.
2. As explained in our earlier replies dated 13 Oct 2008 and 23 Oct 2008, National Service (NS) is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. All male Singaporeans are required to serve NS. We had addressed your issues raised in our earlier replies and will not be making further clarifications on this matter.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/23/2008 07:09 PM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Elizabeth,
Once again, you dodge the essence of my specific questions, and return with bureaucratic platitudes. The policy is plain and you've repeated it to me twice.
But simply repeating what you've been told to say does not address the larger issues I am seeking answers on.
As a representative of an organization that demands 3 years of a young man's life (2 years of service, plus, to be fair, 6 months on either end for transition period), the least you can do is provide an in-depth, specific reply. Otherwise, I am forced to assume that you only know the letter of the law, not the substance.
Thus you miss an opportunity to convince a skeptic. If that is your intention, it reinforces several of my assertions - in particular, that NS damages the intellectual curiosity of young Singaporeans. Further that, by aggressively curtailing the pursuit of independent thought, the government feels no continued need to positively engage those that disagree.
So I once again request precise answers to my pointed questions (I've rephrased them in light of your last reply):
1. What options do you offer those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Please outline what penalties are involved, and know that depending on their severity, they may be in violation of the aforementioned "Universal Declaration of Human Rights" by the United Nations, of which Singapore is a member. I would like you to relay MINDEF's official stance on this. Perhaps there is an acceptable compromise I'm not aware of.
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military?
Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
(To clarify the word exile: To choose between NS and jail is no just choice at all for some people, therefore, this organization forces these folks to 'escape', and then dares to paint them as "cowardly".)
Here is an interesting, somewhat recent article addressing Singapore's "brain-drain". No mention of conscription's impact, but this is as expected from the Straits Times:
http://www.straitstimes.com/Free/Story/STIStory_206290.html
Elizabeth, I am one of those "capable people".
Regards,
David
On Oct 23, 2008, at 5:26 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 14 Oct 2008.
2. We note your feedback on Singapore's policy on National Service (NS). As explained previously, NS is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. Male Singaporeans are therefore deployed to serve their NS only in the Singapore Armed Forces, the Singapore Police Force, or the Singapore Civil Defence Force, where they can contribute directly to the security and defence of Singapore.
3. We thank you for your feedback.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/14/2008 10:20 AM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Elizabeth,
Thanks for your reply, though I am inclined to believe that it is a form reply letter, since some of my specific questions remain unanswered.
You've explained the government's rationale behind "universal" conscription, and yet you fail to realize that the very existence of compulsory enlistment "allow(s) invidious... comparisons to be drawn", namely towards the increasing pool of foreigners who spent those two years establishing their education and career, and have come to Singapore to "enjoy the fruits of Singapore's economic success" (source). Additionally, there is overwhelming evidence that major opportunities in education and employment for Singapore's young men have continually been quashed by this National Service obligation.
The social consequences are already far-reaching, as evidenced by Singapore's relatively high emigration rate, and in how the international community views Singapore on the topic of human rights.
It is no coincidence that this emigration rate only dipped in 2004, when NS laws were slightly relaxed.
As a representative of MINDEF, and with Singapore being a member of the United Nations, you should be aware that National Service violates several portions of the United Nations "Universal Declaration of Human Rights":
Article 20 (2): No one may be compelled to belong to an association.
Article 4: No one shall be held in... servitude.
Article 13 (1): Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each state.
Article 8: No one shall be subjected to arbitrary.... detention or exile.
Etcetera, and be sure to read Article 30 before your reply.
I've already stated my case for why a volunteer system that places emphasis on educational incentives would be better for Singapore in the long-term. And you can read into this argument further at the source I linked to above:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Service_in_Singapore#Humanitarian_efforts
Let me broaden this by saying that my personal resentment would not be so strong if 1) the compulsory time period were kept under 1 year, so as not to so greatly interfere with the more practical pursuit of preparing for financial independence, and if 2) the definition of National Service were expanded to include services beyond the government's military and police apparatus.
An army of motivated, properly paid volunteer professionals can defend Singapore excellently. If subsidized university education becomes part of the package, there would still be a very high number of recruits, and furthermore, their skills and total knowledge would be of much more value to the nation. Military service would be an obvious choice for Singapore's best minds, rather than a forced endeavor that stymieds intellectual development.
To close, I have three specific questions:
1. What options do you offer for those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Beyond Civil Defense - is there no "Civic Defense"?
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
David D'aranjo
On Oct 13, 2008, at 3:58 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email addressed to the Prime Minister's Office regarding National Service (NS) in Singapore.
2. NS is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. With Singapore's inherent resource constraints and vulnerabilities, universal conscription is absolutely critical for our national security. For this reason, all male Singaporeans are required to serve their NS in the Singapore Armed Forces, the Singapore Police Force, or the Singapore Civil Defence Force, where they contribute directly to the security and defence of Singapore.
3. Conscientious objection to military service compromises the universality of NS, thereby undermining Singapore's security. Any concession to particular persons or groups would weaken the principles of universality and equality, the credibility of the NS institution itself, as well as allow invidious and unproductive comparisons to be drawn. These would have far-reaching security and social consequences.
4. A small country like Singapore must have its citizens ready and prepared to defend the country. There remains a high level of support for universal conscription among Singaporeans. The Government will strenuously uphold the NS system, and preserve its fairness and equity. This is essential to maintain the commitment that Singaporeans have shown over four decades of NS.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
----- Forwarded by MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV on 10/13/2008 03:20 PM -----
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV
09/30/2008 05:25 PM
To
daranjo@mac.com
cc
Subject
Fw: NS is not for everybody.
Dear Mr David D'aranjo
MINDEF has received your email addressed to the Prime Minister's Office. We will look into the matter and reply to you as soon as possible.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
"Dave D'aranjo"
21 Sep, 2008 06:29 PM
To
PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Subject
NS is not for everybody.
I am a 24 year old half-Singaporean and half-American. Citizenship-wise, I have renounced my Singaporean citizenship to avoid National Service.
I am a conscientious objector to compulsory enrollment in a military force. I abhor the thought of it for my own reasons. This alternative mindset, however, came with a terrible price: for years I was told that I would be arrested if I stepped foot on Singaporean soil. In effect, this bureaucratic nightmare threatened to cut me off from half of my beloved family. Within the family, our ties have been strained. I have been labelled a whole number of vicious adjectives by others because I disagree with military service. And this obviously has had a sad effect on my identity and concept of "home" - to the effect that for many years, I held on to an infection of hatred for Singapore that I still today cannot truly rationalize.
My first question is, why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? (Your stance is: join our military, or face jail / excommunication). Is it right for a "democratic society, based on justice and equality" to abuse those that disagree, whether it be for moral or religious reasons? (As I understand it, to be a Jehovah's Witness - which I am not - is illegal in Singapore solely for National Service reasons.)
Secondly - as Singapore embraces more and more foreign interests, and more children of mixed-citizenship come of age, how do you expect to demand that all the males, who similarly come from a background where they can see the benefits of a swift university education and have been exposed to foreign cultures, forfeit 2 years of their life? Will you similarly threaten to destroy their sense of place in a society that calls itself compassionate? You also clearly state that dual-nationality is illegal, but "graciously allow" the party to choose either nationality "after they have completed 2 years of NS". How can you justify holding people hostage in this manner in the 21st century?
Here is a scenario that makes more sense to me. End conscription: a volunteer army is one of higher and more honest morale. Turn your enormous resources towards making the military an obvious career choice for all Singaporeans, male and female, by concurrently offering a worldly education as part of the package. Offer would-be enlistees the opportunity to have an international university education, partially subsidized by the government, in return for a subsequent career stint in the military or civil service. Give them incentive to get smart overseas, and return home with their skills.
The benefits of such a system would have a tremendous positive effect on Singaporean society, akin to the social stability of, for instance, Norway. Rather than "buying-in" foreign interests to cover for the lack of knowledge in Singapore's insular society, you would be creating a generation of world-minded scholars to bring the best of the world home - i.e. less dependence or foreign talent. And with that, Singapore's international prestige would rise accordingly, too.
Singapore is a comfortable place to live, but today it also has low birthrates and high emigration. I posit that allowing people more freedom of movement and expression would make people more keen to return to Singapore for the obvious benefits, without making them feel stifled in an intellectual bubble increasingly run economically by foreigners.
Even though I have renounced citizenship, I still consider Singapore my homeland and hope that someday there will again be a place for me there. To be a true "democratic society", Singapore must embrace those young men that would not serve in the military - and offer them compassionate options to ensure they do not leave bitter and without a sense of place.
Please reply immediately to justify your position.
David D'aranjo
Reply to:
Reply to Dave D'aranjo
Reply to Dave D'aranjo Send
Following is a letter from David D'Aranjo on what he thinks of Lee Kuan Yew's award to New York City. I think he is saying that if they want to give that award, they should do it to Pyongyang, North Korea, Harare Zimbabwe or Havana Cuba. They deserve it more than New York city
Best Regards
Gopalan Nair
Fremont, CA, USA
Fwd: NYC is not LKY's "World City".
TO: More recipientsCC: recipientsYou MoreBCC: recipientsYou
Hide Details FROM:Dave D'aranjo Message flagged Thursday, March 22, 2012 2:09 AMA copy of my letter to Singapore's prime minister, Lee Hsien Loong.
Begin forwarded message:
From: Dave D'aranjo
Subject: NYC is not LKY's "World City".
Date: March 22, 2012 5:04:06 AM EDT
To: lee_hsien_loong@pmo.gov.sg, kishore.mahbubani@mahbubani.net
Cc: PMO HQ
Mr. Lee Hsien Loong.
My name is Dave D'aranjo. I have written before.
I am an ex-Singaporean. Your government threatened me with conscription, jail, and/or exile because I did not agree to so-called "universal" conscription. Your military determined that I must be mentally incompetent to hold these views. I renounced my citizenship and was compelled to move to the US, away from home, family, friends, etc.
I was too naive to understand what was happening to me and my family at the time, but suffice to say it seemed earth-shattering.
I will never forget your government's actions against me, and the damage your policies caused to my happiness and sense of home.
I hold you and your father personally responsible - and I am not alone.
When Singapore rejected me, I came to New York City.
New York City offered me a home and acceptance for who I am and what I believe, as long as it meant peace.
Thus I primarily consider myself a New Yorker - by choice and by circumstance.
As a New Yorker, and I would like to tell you that you may pat Mayor Bloomberg on the back and think you both are friends, but the truth is that NYC needs an award from Singapore like a fish needs a bicycle.
Especially an award named after Lee Kuan Yew.
You and your government have no concept of individual liberty, which is - if anything - what NYC represents. The very spirit the of the city is individualistic. Yet your government demands conformity, and the penalties are harsh indeed.
To quote Professor Kishore Mahbubani in the article "New York City gets Lee Kuan Yew prize":
"So [for Singapore] to become the iconic city of the Asian century, we must learn to be more open, accept diversity and take full advantage of it - the way New York City did." - (TodayOnline.com, March 22, 2012)
Why don't you take Professor Mahbubani's advice already? You are failing to perceive and act upon the progressively liberal opinions of Singapore's youth, who are increasingly exasperated and embarrassed about the PAP's authoritarian policies, reliance on "foreign talent", and international reputation. I once had a great love and hope for Singapore, which has (clearly) been decimated.
You may say, "David, that's your view, and you are entitled to it". As an American citizen, I am certainly entitled to a dissenting view. It is a Constitutional right, and there are plenty of advocacy groups that strive for the peaceful reform of government over here. The US is far from perfect, but I am not particularly afraid to speak out. In the news, I witness both great tragedy and great success every day - initiated and effected by the people.
Do Singaporeans really have the right to speak out if they so wish? If I remained a Singaporean, the public expression of these views would put me at risk of censure, detention without limit, jail, lawsuits for defamation that I couldn't hope to afford.... tactics you and your father have capitalized upon in the past with "great success".
It is dirty politics and very much against the grassroots activism that New York City allows for. It is not in the spirit of transformation and 'accepting diversity'. If any American official followed your example, impeachment might not be far behind.
For this reason, let me say that: as long as Singapore is a conservative, restrictive, uptight society that permits corporal punishment, capital punishment, conscription, censorship, and horrendous colonial laws under the false term "Asian Values" -- mark my words -- Singapore will never, ever, EVER in a million years reach the intellectual, historic, humanitarian, scientific and artistic depth that New York City has achieved. Apple co-founder Steve Wozniak somewhat agrees (linked article).
I am angered by your pompous gall at bestowing this made-up "Lee Kuan Yew World City" award to my adoptive home. By naming the award after Lee Kuan Yew, you have undermined the earnest intent of recognizing urban development. The award now reeks of nepotistic authoritarianism.
There's an old expression in New York City -- commonly said; it rhymes with "duck you, you ducking duck".
Let me be the first New Yorker to convey this expression to all involved.
David D'aranjo
On Nov 13, 2008, at 8:31 PM, Dave D'aranjo wrote:
You've no doubt received my previous two emails.
Answer the questions specifically.
David
On Nov 5, 2008, at 8:17 PM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 31 Oct 2008.
2. We had addressed your issues raised in our earlier replies dated 13 Oct 2008, 23 Oct 2008 and 29 Oct 2008, and will not be making further clarifications on this matter.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/31/2008 05:21 PM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO Hsien Loong LEE/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Hi Elizabeth,
I beg to differ - you have not addressed the issues raised, and I am increasingly alarmed that an organization that demands so much is unable to legibly and specifically defend it's own existence.
This is as succinct as I can possibly make my three questions.
Please answer them directly:
1. What options do you offer those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Please outline what penalties or alternatives are involved.
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
I'm asking for three answers, and a couple moments of your time towards a personalized reply.
You ask - no, demand - three years of a young man's life, evidently "no questions asked".
I demand answers as to why I was made to feel like a traitor in a homeland that I otherwise love dearly, simply because I do not believe in participating in the military or police apparatus.
If this were a question of forced religious conscription - vital to "moral" security and defense of a nation - I suspect we'd agree on that scenario's unfair and backwards nature.
I just ask that you be specific; I will not be making further concessions on this matter.
David D'aranjo
On Oct 29, 2008, at 6:25 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 23 Oct 2008.
2. As explained in our earlier replies dated 13 Oct 2008 and 23 Oct 2008, National Service (NS) is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. All male Singaporeans are required to serve NS. We had addressed your issues raised in our earlier replies and will not be making further clarifications on this matter.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/23/2008 07:09 PM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV, PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Elizabeth,
Once again, you dodge the essence of my specific questions, and return with bureaucratic platitudes. The policy is plain and you've repeated it to me twice.
But simply repeating what you've been told to say does not address the larger issues I am seeking answers on.
As a representative of an organization that demands 3 years of a young man's life (2 years of service, plus, to be fair, 6 months on either end for transition period), the least you can do is provide an in-depth, specific reply. Otherwise, I am forced to assume that you only know the letter of the law, not the substance.
Thus you miss an opportunity to convince a skeptic. If that is your intention, it reinforces several of my assertions - in particular, that NS damages the intellectual curiosity of young Singaporeans. Further that, by aggressively curtailing the pursuit of independent thought, the government feels no continued need to positively engage those that disagree.
So I once again request precise answers to my pointed questions (I've rephrased them in light of your last reply):
1. What options do you offer those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Please outline what penalties are involved, and know that depending on their severity, they may be in violation of the aforementioned "Universal Declaration of Human Rights" by the United Nations, of which Singapore is a member. I would like you to relay MINDEF's official stance on this. Perhaps there is an acceptable compromise I'm not aware of.
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military?
Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
(To clarify the word exile: To choose between NS and jail is no just choice at all for some people, therefore, this organization forces these folks to 'escape', and then dares to paint them as "cowardly".)
Here is an interesting, somewhat recent article addressing Singapore's "brain-drain". No mention of conscription's impact, but this is as expected from the Straits Times:
http://www.straitstimes.com/Free/Story/STIStory_206290.html
Elizabeth, I am one of those "capable people".
Regards,
David
On Oct 23, 2008, at 5:26 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email dated 14 Oct 2008.
2. We note your feedback on Singapore's policy on National Service (NS). As explained previously, NS is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. Male Singaporeans are therefore deployed to serve their NS only in the Singapore Armed Forces, the Singapore Police Force, or the Singapore Civil Defence Force, where they can contribute directly to the security and defence of Singapore.
3. We thank you for your feedback.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
Dave D'aranjo
10/14/2008 10:20 AM
To
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Chin Woei SHA/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
Subject
Re: NS is not for everybody.
Elizabeth,
Thanks for your reply, though I am inclined to believe that it is a form reply letter, since some of my specific questions remain unanswered.
You've explained the government's rationale behind "universal" conscription, and yet you fail to realize that the very existence of compulsory enlistment "allow(s) invidious... comparisons to be drawn", namely towards the increasing pool of foreigners who spent those two years establishing their education and career, and have come to Singapore to "enjoy the fruits of Singapore's economic success" (source). Additionally, there is overwhelming evidence that major opportunities in education and employment for Singapore's young men have continually been quashed by this National Service obligation.
The social consequences are already far-reaching, as evidenced by Singapore's relatively high emigration rate, and in how the international community views Singapore on the topic of human rights.
It is no coincidence that this emigration rate only dipped in 2004, when NS laws were slightly relaxed.
As a representative of MINDEF, and with Singapore being a member of the United Nations, you should be aware that National Service violates several portions of the United Nations "Universal Declaration of Human Rights":
Article 20 (2): No one may be compelled to belong to an association.
Article 4: No one shall be held in... servitude.
Article 13 (1): Everyone has the right to freedom of movement and residence within the borders of each state.
Article 8: No one shall be subjected to arbitrary.... detention or exile.
Etcetera, and be sure to read Article 30 before your reply.
I've already stated my case for why a volunteer system that places emphasis on educational incentives would be better for Singapore in the long-term. And you can read into this argument further at the source I linked to above:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Service_in_Singapore#Humanitarian_efforts
Let me broaden this by saying that my personal resentment would not be so strong if 1) the compulsory time period were kept under 1 year, so as not to so greatly interfere with the more practical pursuit of preparing for financial independence, and if 2) the definition of National Service were expanded to include services beyond the government's military and police apparatus.
An army of motivated, properly paid volunteer professionals can defend Singapore excellently. If subsidized university education becomes part of the package, there would still be a very high number of recruits, and furthermore, their skills and total knowledge would be of much more value to the nation. Military service would be an obvious choice for Singapore's best minds, rather than a forced endeavor that stymieds intellectual development.
To close, I have three specific questions:
1. What options do you offer for those that refuse to engage in the activities of the military or police? Beyond Civil Defense - is there no "Civic Defense"?
2. Why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? Is there no other currency of patriotism you accept?
3. Will you reinstate citizenship to those who you have forcibly exiled, and offer them an apology for their grief and for claiming to be a "democratic society based on justice and equality"?
David D'aranjo
On Oct 13, 2008, at 3:58 AM, MINDEF Special Duties wrote:
Dear Mr David D’aranjo
1. I refer to your email addressed to the Prime Minister's Office regarding National Service (NS) in Singapore.
2. NS is a key institution that is vital to the security and defence of Singapore. With Singapore's inherent resource constraints and vulnerabilities, universal conscription is absolutely critical for our national security. For this reason, all male Singaporeans are required to serve their NS in the Singapore Armed Forces, the Singapore Police Force, or the Singapore Civil Defence Force, where they contribute directly to the security and defence of Singapore.
3. Conscientious objection to military service compromises the universality of NS, thereby undermining Singapore's security. Any concession to particular persons or groups would weaken the principles of universality and equality, the credibility of the NS institution itself, as well as allow invidious and unproductive comparisons to be drawn. These would have far-reaching security and social consequences.
4. A small country like Singapore must have its citizens ready and prepared to defend the country. There remains a high level of support for universal conscription among Singaporeans. The Government will strenuously uphold the NS system, and preserve its fairness and equity. This is essential to maintain the commitment that Singaporeans have shown over four decades of NS.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
----- Forwarded by MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV on 10/13/2008 03:20 PM -----
MINDEF Special Duties/MINDEF/SINGOV
09/30/2008 05:25 PM
To
daranjo@mac.com
cc
Subject
Fw: NS is not for everybody.
Dear Mr David D'aranjo
MINDEF has received your email addressed to the Prime Minister's Office. We will look into the matter and reply to you as soon as possible.
Yours sincerely
MS ELIZABETH TAN
for PERMANENT SECRETARY
MINISTRY OF DEFENCE
"Dave D'aranjo"
21 Sep, 2008 06:29 PM
To
PMO HQ/PMO/SINGOV@SINGOV
cc
Subject
NS is not for everybody.
I am a 24 year old half-Singaporean and half-American. Citizenship-wise, I have renounced my Singaporean citizenship to avoid National Service.
I am a conscientious objector to compulsory enrollment in a military force. I abhor the thought of it for my own reasons. This alternative mindset, however, came with a terrible price: for years I was told that I would be arrested if I stepped foot on Singaporean soil. In effect, this bureaucratic nightmare threatened to cut me off from half of my beloved family. Within the family, our ties have been strained. I have been labelled a whole number of vicious adjectives by others because I disagree with military service. And this obviously has had a sad effect on my identity and concept of "home" - to the effect that for many years, I held on to an infection of hatred for Singapore that I still today cannot truly rationalize.
My first question is, why was I put through emotional and bureaucratic hell, with no viable alternative path, simply because I objected to joining your military? (Your stance is: join our military, or face jail / excommunication). Is it right for a "democratic society, based on justice and equality" to abuse those that disagree, whether it be for moral or religious reasons? (As I understand it, to be a Jehovah's Witness - which I am not - is illegal in Singapore solely for National Service reasons.)
Secondly - as Singapore embraces more and more foreign interests, and more children of mixed-citizenship come of age, how do you expect to demand that all the males, who similarly come from a background where they can see the benefits of a swift university education and have been exposed to foreign cultures, forfeit 2 years of their life? Will you similarly threaten to destroy their sense of place in a society that calls itself compassionate? You also clearly state that dual-nationality is illegal, but "graciously allow" the party to choose either nationality "after they have completed 2 years of NS". How can you justify holding people hostage in this manner in the 21st century?
Here is a scenario that makes more sense to me. End conscription: a volunteer army is one of higher and more honest morale. Turn your enormous resources towards making the military an obvious career choice for all Singaporeans, male and female, by concurrently offering a worldly education as part of the package. Offer would-be enlistees the opportunity to have an international university education, partially subsidized by the government, in return for a subsequent career stint in the military or civil service. Give them incentive to get smart overseas, and return home with their skills.
The benefits of such a system would have a tremendous positive effect on Singaporean society, akin to the social stability of, for instance, Norway. Rather than "buying-in" foreign interests to cover for the lack of knowledge in Singapore's insular society, you would be creating a generation of world-minded scholars to bring the best of the world home - i.e. less dependence or foreign talent. And with that, Singapore's international prestige would rise accordingly, too.
Singapore is a comfortable place to live, but today it also has low birthrates and high emigration. I posit that allowing people more freedom of movement and expression would make people more keen to return to Singapore for the obvious benefits, without making them feel stifled in an intellectual bubble increasingly run economically by foreigners.
Even though I have renounced citizenship, I still consider Singapore my homeland and hope that someday there will again be a place for me there. To be a true "democratic society", Singapore must embrace those young men that would not serve in the military - and offer them compassionate options to ensure they do not leave bitter and without a sense of place.
Please reply immediately to justify your position.
David D'aranjo
Reply to:
Reply to Dave D'aranjo
Reply to Dave D'aranjo Send
Alan Sahdrake honored in London
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Below is an Email received from Alan Sahdrake, the author of Once a Jolly Hangman. Congratulations Alan Sahdrake.
Very Best Regards
Gopalan Nair, Fremont, California
Dear Gopalan, you might be interested in mentioning that Once a Jolly Hangman made
the George Orwell Prize Longlist for 2012. Just been announced in London and the winners
will be announced at a ceremony in late April. It's also on Facebook and Twitter. If you
can help spread the news that would be great - dont we just love poking him in the eye
as often as possible!
Love your last blog, by the way.
Alan
Below is an Email received from Alan Sahdrake, the author of Once a Jolly Hangman. Congratulations Alan Sahdrake.
Very Best Regards
Gopalan Nair, Fremont, California
Dear Gopalan, you might be interested in mentioning that Once a Jolly Hangman made
the George Orwell Prize Longlist for 2012. Just been announced in London and the winners
will be announced at a ceremony in late April. It's also on Facebook and Twitter. If you
can help spread the news that would be great - dont we just love poking him in the eye
as often as possible!
Love your last blog, by the way.
Alan
Sunday, April 8, 2012
Singaporean's double lives
Ladies and Gentlemen,
An entire island of 5.1 million people in Singapore live, literally speaking, double lives. They have to behave one way when they know the reality is another.
You have an island which in reality is a one party fascist state. The Lee ruling family of Singapore literally control everything, own everything and run everything through their Peoples Action Party which has been continually running the island since 1959. They pay themselves each $5.7 million a year each. This is simply theft and corruption.
They control all the newspapers and media. Any information about the island and official matters are strictly controlled. The people get to hear what they want them to hear. What you get is propaganda, no different from what you would get in North Korea.
The judges are personally appointed by the Lee family who willingly, as part of their duties punish and destroy political opponents through the misuse of the law. There is no rule of law with the legal system completely politicized. Government cronies and rich foreign bankers receive preferential treatment; ordinary people without any connections are dealt with more harshly while government opponents and critics receive the blunt end of the stick. The people have lost faith in the law.
Workers are denied the right to freely organize. Union leaders are appointed by the government to protect employers and any attempt to strike or go slow will result in imprisonment.
Singapore’s Lee ruling family prohibits constitutional rights including free speech, expression and assembly and any attempt to do this will result in arrest, imprisonment and permanent harassment and victimization in the future in all walks of life. You will lose your job, you will be falsely charged with criminal offenses and until such time as you repent and submit, your life would be Hell.
I am one such victim of the Lee ruling family's wrath. Since 1984, after openly joining the former Workers Party and contesting elections and continuing to be a government critic ever since, my picture has been repeatedly published in their state controlled press, media and television. That was a signal that henceforth I should be denied any privileges whatsoever. In 2008 after I had criticized one of Lee's judges Belinda Ang Saw Ean while in Singapore, for shamelessly abusing the law against Lee's political opponent Chee Soon Juan in court, I was sentenced to 3 months imprisonment and subsequently disbarred from practicing law in Singapore. For the rest of my life Lee’s Singapore will deny any privileges to me which others might be allowed.
Thanks very much but I have no intention to stop my criticism,
Everyone in Singapore with eyes can see these injustices. Yet Singaporeans go along and pretend as if there is nothing wrong.
Take a Singapore Air Force pilot who flies for his country, a country which he knows has no rule of law, a country which denies him a right to free speech and expression, a country that would sue him for defamation of character if he ever criticized the Lee family and where they pay themselves 5 times the salary of the President of the United States, which is theft.
How does a pilot risk his life and fight for a country such as this? An American pilot when he files for the USA knows that he is defending America, which despite all its faults has the rule of law, a respect for the Constitution and place where he has rights. A Singapore pilot who knows as much as I do about his country may want to drop a bomb over Lee Kuan Yew's house instead of defending them.
Consider any Singapore lawyer. He knows that the courts before which he appears is nothing other than Lee Kuan Yew's tools to silence the opposition and any attempt to challenge them; whereas an American lawyer knows when he steps into that courtroom that he can expect justice regardless of who he is, rich or poor, connected or not. An American lawyer has no problem practicing his profession with his conscience intact. How does a Singapore lawyer do it?
A teacher in Singapore’s schools knows the importance of her students speaking the truth, the importance of such qualities as integrity, honesty and courage. What good is an education if you do not have integrity?
Yet she knows that if she told her students to speak the truth, she would lose her job. She has no choice but to lie about the greatness of Lee Kuan Yew just as a North Korean teacher would have to lie about the greatness of Kim Jong An. She cannot tell her students that Singapore strongman Lee is actually a dictator even though it is true. Poor woman. She does it because she needs a job and not so confident of going it alone in Australia.
It is not a very pleasant existence, not for the teacher and neither for the student.
And the same applies to every single human being in the island from the civil servant to the taxi driver. They all know as much as I do. Yet they have to go along with their lives as if Singapore was a democracy. They have to pretend that its judges are independent. They have to pretend as if their courts are independent and they have to pretend as if they have freedom.
This sort of a double life could have gone on perfectly well 20 years ago, but it is simply not possible now. In 1982 Hafiz al Assad could have murdered several thousands of Syrians and be none the worse for it, but not his son in 2012 with the Internet.
Although the Lee ruling family can crack down with brutal force against his detractors now, the ease with which people can cross borders today and the fact that news cannot be stopped from spreading via the Internet makes their attempts to continue by doing one thing and pretending something else more and more difficult.
True, with a state controlled media, you can say anything you want but when the people don't believe it anymore, it becomes increasingly difficult to enforce your rule. In this distasteful lifestyle, people with the luxury of leaving will leave, and building better roads and water canals to beautify the island as they do now, cannot compensate for the distaste of living double lives.
I am not sure whether a Singapore Air Force pilot in one of his sorties carrying live bomb payload will decide to change course one fine day from his live firing target to turn Lee Kuan Yew's house into one, a target.
Neither am I sure when or if any army officer would decide to drive his tanks to that same house and discharge a volley of shells and finish off the Lee family once and for all.
I am not sure if any of this would happen and if it does when. But one thing I am sure which is this. The rot continues. Singaporeans continue to emigrate in droves to Australia and the West. The rate of childbirth continues to be the lowest in the world and the increasing older generation is simply dying off. In their place are brought in recent Communist Chinese looking for work and some from the West to work as off shore lawyers and bankers. None of them care a wink for the interests of the island.
Since being dedicated and loyal to a corrupt regime by anyone is impossible, Lee Kuan Yew's Singapore has completely lost anyone with a real passion or love for their country.
On the other hand it is not hard for an American to love and respect his country. It has a constitution and laws which are respected. It is not run by any family such as Singapore’s Lee ruling family, telling them what can and cannot be done, or what is permitted and what forbidden.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
An entire island of 5.1 million people in Singapore live, literally speaking, double lives. They have to behave one way when they know the reality is another.
You have an island which in reality is a one party fascist state. The Lee ruling family of Singapore literally control everything, own everything and run everything through their Peoples Action Party which has been continually running the island since 1959. They pay themselves each $5.7 million a year each. This is simply theft and corruption.
They control all the newspapers and media. Any information about the island and official matters are strictly controlled. The people get to hear what they want them to hear. What you get is propaganda, no different from what you would get in North Korea.
The judges are personally appointed by the Lee family who willingly, as part of their duties punish and destroy political opponents through the misuse of the law. There is no rule of law with the legal system completely politicized. Government cronies and rich foreign bankers receive preferential treatment; ordinary people without any connections are dealt with more harshly while government opponents and critics receive the blunt end of the stick. The people have lost faith in the law.
Workers are denied the right to freely organize. Union leaders are appointed by the government to protect employers and any attempt to strike or go slow will result in imprisonment.
Singapore’s Lee ruling family prohibits constitutional rights including free speech, expression and assembly and any attempt to do this will result in arrest, imprisonment and permanent harassment and victimization in the future in all walks of life. You will lose your job, you will be falsely charged with criminal offenses and until such time as you repent and submit, your life would be Hell.
I am one such victim of the Lee ruling family's wrath. Since 1984, after openly joining the former Workers Party and contesting elections and continuing to be a government critic ever since, my picture has been repeatedly published in their state controlled press, media and television. That was a signal that henceforth I should be denied any privileges whatsoever. In 2008 after I had criticized one of Lee's judges Belinda Ang Saw Ean while in Singapore, for shamelessly abusing the law against Lee's political opponent Chee Soon Juan in court, I was sentenced to 3 months imprisonment and subsequently disbarred from practicing law in Singapore. For the rest of my life Lee’s Singapore will deny any privileges to me which others might be allowed.
Thanks very much but I have no intention to stop my criticism,
Everyone in Singapore with eyes can see these injustices. Yet Singaporeans go along and pretend as if there is nothing wrong.
Take a Singapore Air Force pilot who flies for his country, a country which he knows has no rule of law, a country which denies him a right to free speech and expression, a country that would sue him for defamation of character if he ever criticized the Lee family and where they pay themselves 5 times the salary of the President of the United States, which is theft.
How does a pilot risk his life and fight for a country such as this? An American pilot when he files for the USA knows that he is defending America, which despite all its faults has the rule of law, a respect for the Constitution and place where he has rights. A Singapore pilot who knows as much as I do about his country may want to drop a bomb over Lee Kuan Yew's house instead of defending them.
Consider any Singapore lawyer. He knows that the courts before which he appears is nothing other than Lee Kuan Yew's tools to silence the opposition and any attempt to challenge them; whereas an American lawyer knows when he steps into that courtroom that he can expect justice regardless of who he is, rich or poor, connected or not. An American lawyer has no problem practicing his profession with his conscience intact. How does a Singapore lawyer do it?
A teacher in Singapore’s schools knows the importance of her students speaking the truth, the importance of such qualities as integrity, honesty and courage. What good is an education if you do not have integrity?
Yet she knows that if she told her students to speak the truth, she would lose her job. She has no choice but to lie about the greatness of Lee Kuan Yew just as a North Korean teacher would have to lie about the greatness of Kim Jong An. She cannot tell her students that Singapore strongman Lee is actually a dictator even though it is true. Poor woman. She does it because she needs a job and not so confident of going it alone in Australia.
It is not a very pleasant existence, not for the teacher and neither for the student.
And the same applies to every single human being in the island from the civil servant to the taxi driver. They all know as much as I do. Yet they have to go along with their lives as if Singapore was a democracy. They have to pretend that its judges are independent. They have to pretend as if their courts are independent and they have to pretend as if they have freedom.
This sort of a double life could have gone on perfectly well 20 years ago, but it is simply not possible now. In 1982 Hafiz al Assad could have murdered several thousands of Syrians and be none the worse for it, but not his son in 2012 with the Internet.
Although the Lee ruling family can crack down with brutal force against his detractors now, the ease with which people can cross borders today and the fact that news cannot be stopped from spreading via the Internet makes their attempts to continue by doing one thing and pretending something else more and more difficult.
True, with a state controlled media, you can say anything you want but when the people don't believe it anymore, it becomes increasingly difficult to enforce your rule. In this distasteful lifestyle, people with the luxury of leaving will leave, and building better roads and water canals to beautify the island as they do now, cannot compensate for the distaste of living double lives.
I am not sure whether a Singapore Air Force pilot in one of his sorties carrying live bomb payload will decide to change course one fine day from his live firing target to turn Lee Kuan Yew's house into one, a target.
Neither am I sure when or if any army officer would decide to drive his tanks to that same house and discharge a volley of shells and finish off the Lee family once and for all.
I am not sure if any of this would happen and if it does when. But one thing I am sure which is this. The rot continues. Singaporeans continue to emigrate in droves to Australia and the West. The rate of childbirth continues to be the lowest in the world and the increasing older generation is simply dying off. In their place are brought in recent Communist Chinese looking for work and some from the West to work as off shore lawyers and bankers. None of them care a wink for the interests of the island.
Since being dedicated and loyal to a corrupt regime by anyone is impossible, Lee Kuan Yew's Singapore has completely lost anyone with a real passion or love for their country.
On the other hand it is not hard for an American to love and respect his country. It has a constitution and laws which are respected. It is not run by any family such as Singapore’s Lee ruling family, telling them what can and cannot be done, or what is permitted and what forbidden.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Thursday, April 5, 2012
Singapore. The moment is now for peaceful protest and street demonstrations.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Singapore Lee ruling family's grip on power is now extremely tenuous. Difficulties are mounting for them on several fronts. They have seen their lowest majority at the elections in 2011, a mere 62% despite the fact a large segment of the population are recent immigrants who know nothing of Singapore and would naturally vote for anyone in power even if they were donkeys.
You have the ever increasing problem of the unstoppable brain drain with the loss of the most talented of Singaporeans, a crippling blow paralysing their ability to govern.
Only yesterday Lee's son, the Prime Minister whom he appointed, publicly admitted a growing divide between recent immigrants and native Singaporeans. We hear of daily confrontation including violent ones between them.
As for the Lee ruling family, they are finding it increasingly difficult in attracting qualified candidates into their ranks despite the lure of astronomical salaries running into millions of dollars, made up of salaries, and bribes and kickbacks.
I believe the reason for this; people have no longer confidence in their continued rule since it is widely expected that with the demise of the 89 year old autocrat Lee, which is going to happen very soon, the island will descend into chaos and disorder, the reason being the son is widely believed as incapable of ruling without his father behind him for support.
On top of that you have to suffer the lack of civil liberties; a denial of a free press and instead you get propaganda, the denial of the right to protest, a fear ridden society worshipping the Lee family who appear as Gods, while they steal millions of your dollars calling it salaries.
This is the moment for you if you want to bring down this Lee ruling family dynasty and introduce democracy like they have done in all the Middle East and numerous other countries in the world. Even Burma is changing for the better. The Burmese have had the courage to come out and vote for Aung San Su Chi and freedom.
I am not asking anyone to resort to violence. Remember that under the Singapore Constitution, you have a right to free speech and expression and assembly, provided it is done in peace.
The requirements placed by the Lee ruling family requiring permits for such activity is illegal under the law as the Constitution is sacrosanct and no amendment of its provisions is allowed except for grave national emergency which does not exist.
Although you might be prosecuted by this repressive dictatorial regime for engaging in this lawful activity, such prosecutions are illegal under natural justice. Remember both under international law and under natural justice you are committing no wrong. Indeed your actions would be of the highest of honorable conduct expected of a loyal patriotic citizen.
Please do not waste your time protesting in Hong Lim park because you need not comply with that requirement. The law entitles you to protest in any public place in Singapore provided you are not obstructing or trespassing into anyone else's person or property.
It is going to be very hard for them to portray you as a criminal for doing this, since the world's greatest human beings have all engaged in peaceful protest such as Gandhi and Martin Luther King. If indeed men like them were criminals, surely it is an honor to be a criminal.
Just imagine how much effect you would have if you stood at Raffles Place at lunch hour holding up a placard for freedom. You are not obstructing anyone, you are not hurting anyone, you are in peace speaking your mind as a good citizen should.
There are many Singaporeans who have travelled abroad and know that such activity is routinely carried out in Sydney, Melbourne, London and any other free city in the world. The Lee ruling family has no right to stop you doing this in your own country.
Far too many people in Singapore have already seen the other side of the hill. Singaporeans know how much fun it is to live free. I do as I live in California. At the same time I wish to see a free and democratic Singapore as I am sure you, the reader of Singapore Dissident, also do.
So my friends, do it. The moment is now. I would love to see to faces of the Lee family when this actually happens. Remember it is 2012 now. Not 1960. Once someone does it, I am absolutely sure, it would spread like wildfire across the island. And you would come out of this a free man no longer in bondage.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Singapore Lee ruling family's grip on power is now extremely tenuous. Difficulties are mounting for them on several fronts. They have seen their lowest majority at the elections in 2011, a mere 62% despite the fact a large segment of the population are recent immigrants who know nothing of Singapore and would naturally vote for anyone in power even if they were donkeys.
You have the ever increasing problem of the unstoppable brain drain with the loss of the most talented of Singaporeans, a crippling blow paralysing their ability to govern.
Only yesterday Lee's son, the Prime Minister whom he appointed, publicly admitted a growing divide between recent immigrants and native Singaporeans. We hear of daily confrontation including violent ones between them.
As for the Lee ruling family, they are finding it increasingly difficult in attracting qualified candidates into their ranks despite the lure of astronomical salaries running into millions of dollars, made up of salaries, and bribes and kickbacks.
I believe the reason for this; people have no longer confidence in their continued rule since it is widely expected that with the demise of the 89 year old autocrat Lee, which is going to happen very soon, the island will descend into chaos and disorder, the reason being the son is widely believed as incapable of ruling without his father behind him for support.
On top of that you have to suffer the lack of civil liberties; a denial of a free press and instead you get propaganda, the denial of the right to protest, a fear ridden society worshipping the Lee family who appear as Gods, while they steal millions of your dollars calling it salaries.
This is the moment for you if you want to bring down this Lee ruling family dynasty and introduce democracy like they have done in all the Middle East and numerous other countries in the world. Even Burma is changing for the better. The Burmese have had the courage to come out and vote for Aung San Su Chi and freedom.
I am not asking anyone to resort to violence. Remember that under the Singapore Constitution, you have a right to free speech and expression and assembly, provided it is done in peace.
The requirements placed by the Lee ruling family requiring permits for such activity is illegal under the law as the Constitution is sacrosanct and no amendment of its provisions is allowed except for grave national emergency which does not exist.
Although you might be prosecuted by this repressive dictatorial regime for engaging in this lawful activity, such prosecutions are illegal under natural justice. Remember both under international law and under natural justice you are committing no wrong. Indeed your actions would be of the highest of honorable conduct expected of a loyal patriotic citizen.
Please do not waste your time protesting in Hong Lim park because you need not comply with that requirement. The law entitles you to protest in any public place in Singapore provided you are not obstructing or trespassing into anyone else's person or property.
It is going to be very hard for them to portray you as a criminal for doing this, since the world's greatest human beings have all engaged in peaceful protest such as Gandhi and Martin Luther King. If indeed men like them were criminals, surely it is an honor to be a criminal.
Just imagine how much effect you would have if you stood at Raffles Place at lunch hour holding up a placard for freedom. You are not obstructing anyone, you are not hurting anyone, you are in peace speaking your mind as a good citizen should.
There are many Singaporeans who have travelled abroad and know that such activity is routinely carried out in Sydney, Melbourne, London and any other free city in the world. The Lee ruling family has no right to stop you doing this in your own country.
Far too many people in Singapore have already seen the other side of the hill. Singaporeans know how much fun it is to live free. I do as I live in California. At the same time I wish to see a free and democratic Singapore as I am sure you, the reader of Singapore Dissident, also do.
So my friends, do it. The moment is now. I would love to see to faces of the Lee family when this actually happens. Remember it is 2012 now. Not 1960. Once someone does it, I am absolutely sure, it would spread like wildfire across the island. And you would come out of this a free man no longer in bondage.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Wednesday, April 4, 2012
Singapore. Totalitarian rule and it's consequences.
Ladies and Gentlemen,
Singaporeans in truth have no rights to speak of. Their Constitution has been repeatedly amended to take away their right to free speech, free expression or assembly all of whom now need a government permit, which will be denied if anyone applied to speak against them. You have a judiciary which has routinely been used as a political tool against government critics, as a result of which it has been totally discredited.
You have a Prime Minister who was not freely and fairly elected but was placed there by his father who has the puppet strings. No one respects the son and just ignores him as if he wasn't even there.
As for the father who is 89, he continues to orchestrate the the government from behind the scenes as if the island was the personal property of his family.
And unlike in the past when news did not spread as quickly as they do now with the Internet, it is no longer possible to keep these government excesses under wraps. The result of all this is a Singaporean public which is totally detached and unconcerned with how the island is run, as if they were all there temporarily to make a living and then leave the island.
The massive numbers of recent immigrants, the majority of whom have been given citizenship not only do not care about what goes on, they do not know anything about Singapore either.
If the Lee ruling family still manages to govern Singapore they are not managing it because the people support them but because they are afraid of Lee's police force and the courts which he controls. It is simply an island which is governed through fear, not voluntary intelligent support.
Which is why cracks are increasingly appearing in the cohesion among the people resulting in dislike even hatred among the citizens. Look at what is happening. The state Controlled newspaper the Straits Times of April 05, 2012 has the story "PM Lee flags two worrying trends in Singapore", http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_785443.html.
It talks of the "growing divide" between native citizens and new immigrants, mainly from Communist China. With the ever increasing Communist Chinese population component in Singapore which has nothing either socially or historically in common with the locals, there are going to be more and more violent clashes between them, which is already happening, resulting in society disintegrating.
Not too long ago, you had a Communist Chinese immigrant family who complained about their Singaporean Indian neighbours cooking curry because they didn't like its smell. As a result the Indian family were coerced into voluntarily not cooking it when these Communist Chinese neighbours were in, a strange concession for someone giving up the right to cook a dish in their own home.
After this incident, to the credit of Singaporean Chinese (as opposed to these Communist China imports) who have always lived in harmony with their Indian neighbours, many in fact went out of their way to support their Indian friends and told these Communist Chinese to just get out of the country altogether if they didn't like it.
On April 2, 2012, there was an article in this state controlled press headed "Intellectual Property office of Singapore gets new subsidiary" http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_784520.html,
the story talks of this government office setting up a subsidiary called IP Academy by which they hope to become a hub for the practice of Intellectual property law.
I think this is once again just fat hopes. It will not succeed. Any law jurisdiction hoping to prosper has to be first of all respected. With Singapore's judiciary and it's legal system totally discredited for being seen as a tool to silence dissent though abusing the law, the international community has lost all faith in it. Judges like Belinda Ang Saw Ean are in fact doubling as PAP politicians, not judges, when they bankrupt a critic Chee Soon Juan with astronomical court awards merely for voicing criticism agaisnt the government.
Since Intellectual Property law just as any other law does not exist in a vacuum but is interrelated with other areas of law including the Constitution, since the Lee ruling family have completely deprived Singaporeans of any constitutional rights, the impartially of the courts can no longer be expected. Such a jurisdiction, like that of North Korea or Communist China has no hope of becoming any hub for any legal discipline.
What the Lee ruling family should understand is this. The moment you think of abusing the rule of law for your own political ends, that is when you get hurt from all sides. The people have no respect for you, there is not going to be any dedication and you are simply not going to get the real support of your people. They may keep quiet and simply go along but such obedience is extracted out of fear, not out of any support from your people. And a society like this only descends further into abyss of shame and disrespect.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Singaporeans in truth have no rights to speak of. Their Constitution has been repeatedly amended to take away their right to free speech, free expression or assembly all of whom now need a government permit, which will be denied if anyone applied to speak against them. You have a judiciary which has routinely been used as a political tool against government critics, as a result of which it has been totally discredited.
You have a Prime Minister who was not freely and fairly elected but was placed there by his father who has the puppet strings. No one respects the son and just ignores him as if he wasn't even there.
As for the father who is 89, he continues to orchestrate the the government from behind the scenes as if the island was the personal property of his family.
And unlike in the past when news did not spread as quickly as they do now with the Internet, it is no longer possible to keep these government excesses under wraps. The result of all this is a Singaporean public which is totally detached and unconcerned with how the island is run, as if they were all there temporarily to make a living and then leave the island.
The massive numbers of recent immigrants, the majority of whom have been given citizenship not only do not care about what goes on, they do not know anything about Singapore either.
If the Lee ruling family still manages to govern Singapore they are not managing it because the people support them but because they are afraid of Lee's police force and the courts which he controls. It is simply an island which is governed through fear, not voluntary intelligent support.
Which is why cracks are increasingly appearing in the cohesion among the people resulting in dislike even hatred among the citizens. Look at what is happening. The state Controlled newspaper the Straits Times of April 05, 2012 has the story "PM Lee flags two worrying trends in Singapore", http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_785443.html.
It talks of the "growing divide" between native citizens and new immigrants, mainly from Communist China. With the ever increasing Communist Chinese population component in Singapore which has nothing either socially or historically in common with the locals, there are going to be more and more violent clashes between them, which is already happening, resulting in society disintegrating.
Not too long ago, you had a Communist Chinese immigrant family who complained about their Singaporean Indian neighbours cooking curry because they didn't like its smell. As a result the Indian family were coerced into voluntarily not cooking it when these Communist Chinese neighbours were in, a strange concession for someone giving up the right to cook a dish in their own home.
After this incident, to the credit of Singaporean Chinese (as opposed to these Communist China imports) who have always lived in harmony with their Indian neighbours, many in fact went out of their way to support their Indian friends and told these Communist Chinese to just get out of the country altogether if they didn't like it.
On April 2, 2012, there was an article in this state controlled press headed "Intellectual Property office of Singapore gets new subsidiary" http://www.straitstimes.com/BreakingNews/Singapore/Story/STIStory_784520.html,
the story talks of this government office setting up a subsidiary called IP Academy by which they hope to become a hub for the practice of Intellectual property law.
I think this is once again just fat hopes. It will not succeed. Any law jurisdiction hoping to prosper has to be first of all respected. With Singapore's judiciary and it's legal system totally discredited for being seen as a tool to silence dissent though abusing the law, the international community has lost all faith in it. Judges like Belinda Ang Saw Ean are in fact doubling as PAP politicians, not judges, when they bankrupt a critic Chee Soon Juan with astronomical court awards merely for voicing criticism agaisnt the government.
Since Intellectual Property law just as any other law does not exist in a vacuum but is interrelated with other areas of law including the Constitution, since the Lee ruling family have completely deprived Singaporeans of any constitutional rights, the impartially of the courts can no longer be expected. Such a jurisdiction, like that of North Korea or Communist China has no hope of becoming any hub for any legal discipline.
What the Lee ruling family should understand is this. The moment you think of abusing the rule of law for your own political ends, that is when you get hurt from all sides. The people have no respect for you, there is not going to be any dedication and you are simply not going to get the real support of your people. They may keep quiet and simply go along but such obedience is extracted out of fear, not out of any support from your people. And a society like this only descends further into abyss of shame and disrespect.
Gopalan Nair
Attorney at Law
Disbarred from practicing law in Lee's Singapore, imprisoned and refused entry to the island for criticizing Singapore's judiciary in this blog (see blogpost May 29, 2008 Singapore. Judge Belinda Ang's Kangaroo Court)
Actively practicing law in California and in good standing at the California Bar.
Member in good standing as a lawyer in England and Wales (Barrister).
39737 Paseo Padre Parkway, Suite A1
Fremont, CA 94538, USA
Tel: 510 657 6107
Fax: 510 657 6914
Email: nair.gopalan@yahoo.com
Blog: http://singaporedissident.blogspot.com/
Your letters are welcome. We reserve the right to publish your letters. Please Email your letters to nair.gopalan@yahoo.com And if you like what I write, please tell your friends. You will be helping democracy by distributing this widely. This blog not only gives information, it dispels government propaganda put out by this dictatorial regime.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
